Visa refusals: what to do
Federal Court and mandamus
Temporary visas
Principles for Deciding Visa Applications
Immigration officers who assess applications for permanent and temporary visas must follow several principles of procedural fairness throughout the process of handling the documents.
The rules require officers to:
- assess applications objectively and fairly;
- notify applicants of concerns that arise; and
- give applicants an opportunity to respond to the officer's concerns about their documents and information.
Procedural fairness requirements apply to all types of immigration and citizenship applications and to every aspect of decision-making.
The main elements of procedural fairness are:
- Document review must not be delayed without reason.
- The applicant has a right to a fair and impartial decision.
- The applicant has a right to be heard.
- The person who hears the application must make the decision.
- The applicant's legitimate expectations.
- The decision must be based on the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act and Regulations.
- The right to reasons.
No undue delay
Every application must be processed without unreasonable delay. In other words, work should be done on the application throughout the time it is under consideration; it cannot simply be put aside without reason.
The right to a fair and impartial decision
Applicants have a right to fair and impartial decision-making. Court decisions have repeatedly confirmed that officers must avoid all bias.
Examples of bias can include:
- Making a decision without a detailed review of the documents.
- Prejudice against an applicant who has previously been refused.
- An existing relationship between the decision-maker and the applicant (for example, a financial interest or family relationship), and so on.
The applicant's right to be heard
Applicants have a right to know the requirements they must meet and must be given a fair opportunity to provide all necessary information.
The "right to be heard" requires applicants to be informed of significant facts that may affect the outcome of their applications. For example, if an officer uses outside information (that is, information obtained from sources other than the applicant) when assessing an application, the officer must tell the applicant and give them an opportunity to comment on it.
The officer must give the applicant enough time to gather additional documents. The officer must provide a list of the documents needed to make a decision.
The right to be heard does not necessarily include a right to an interview, although an interview may be the most appropriate option in some cases. If the applicant is interviewed, they must be allowed to use an interpreter.
It is important that the officer's concerns be communicated to the applicant before a decision is made and that the applicant be given a reasonable opportunity to respond to and refute them.
The person who hears the application must decide
If one officer assesses an application, clearly that officer should decide it. In practice, however, different people may work on it. It is therefore important that all documents submitted by the applicant be placed in the record (whether electronic or paper) for the person making the final decision to review. The decision record should also show that the decision-maker weighed all relevant factors, including everything the applicant submitted, and based the decision on the whole body of information.
If a subjective assessment is involved in making the decision (for example, assessing the credibility of information provided), the record should clearly indicate that the decision-maker made that assessment. The decision-maker should not rely on someone else's subjective assessment; they should make the decision themselves based on full information and give objective reasons for it.
This does not mean that the deciding officer cannot seek advice from a supervisor or colleague before making the final decision. The decision record should, however, show that after assessing all relevant factors, the officer reached their own conclusions.
Legitimate expectations
If an applicant is told what procedure will be followed in submitting and assessing an application, they have a right to expect that the procedure will be followed as described.
For example, if an applicant is given 30 days to provide certain documents, they have a right to expect that no decision will be made before the 30-day period ends, even if some requested documents are submitted earlier.
The decision must follow the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act and Regulations
A refusal letter must identify specific provisions of the Act or Regulations. All correspondence to the applicant, including refusal letters, must refer to the relevant legislative provisions.
In many situations, the time available to resolve problems is limited by law, and some options disappear when those deadlines pass. The earlier the facts are assessed, the more options remain.
The right to reasons
Applicants have a right to receive reasons for decisions on their applications. The reasons must be in writing and must be clear, precise and understandable.
When an applicant has a right to appeal or seek a Federal Court review of a decision, they need enough information to prepare their application. The reasons given to the applicant should reflect an assessment of the facts and evidence they cite, the provision or provisions of the Act and/or Regulations on which the decision is based, and the rationale for the decision-maker's conclusion.
Breaches of procedural fairness
In practice, procedural fairness principles are often not followed, generally because of mistakes by immigration officers, imprecise wording, and other reasons.
It is important to remember that a breach of procedural fairness is one of the substantial grounds for seeking review of a decision on an application.
In many situations, the time available to resolve problems is limited by law, and some options disappear when those deadlines pass. The earlier the facts are assessed, the more options remain.