Laws of Software Development in Legal Practice
The development of the modern IT industry has led to the discovery of a number of laws, much as the apple that, according to legend, fell on Newton's head in the 17th century led to the discovery of the law of universal gravitation.
It is interesting how many of these laws, sometimes called laws of software development for simplicity, also operate in legal immigration practice.
Brooks's law:
Adding new people to a project that is already behind schedule generally delays it further.
This happens because of the added complexity of coordination and training.
This is perhaps the clearest and simplest example of a software law working in another field. Exactly the same thing happens in legal practice: if more staff are brought into an urgent task, either it is delayed by the resulting complications or other tasks suffer because time is spent overcoming those complications.
Goodhart's law:
When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a reliable measure of success.
In other words, when immigration authorities make shorter visa-application processing times their main goal, other things suffer, above all the quality of decisions: there are more unjustified refusals and administrative errors (and a greater burden on the Federal Court and other bodies that review such cases). Processing times become shorter and the goal is met, but the overall quality of work declines.
Hyrum's Law:
If a system is used by many people, almost any behaviour of that system will inevitably be relied on by someone, even if it is not officially provided for.
An illustrative example: according to its official documentation, an IT system should return a list of files in a random order, but in practice it returns them alphabetically. Users notice and start organizing their work on the assumption that the list will be alphabetical. If the system changes and returns the files in an arbitrary order, many users' work will be disrupted.
When users rely on undocumented features, the orderly development of that system becomes much more difficult.
Another example is making a refugee claim after crossing a land border outside an official port of entry. Immigration law did not provide this opportunity to those who crossed into Canada legally because the United States was considered a safe country. But there was no such prohibition for migrants who crossed at unauthorized places. As a result, thousands of people entered Canada by the notorious Roxham Road and were able to make refugee claims.
In legislation, such things are usually called loopholes, but in substance this is Hyrum's Law.
Hofstadter's law:
Completing any task always takes longer than you expect, even when you take Hofstadter's law into account.
This is one of the fundamental laws and needs no explanation: experience shows that it applies in most cases. Circumstances always arise that affect the course of events and, as a result, make tasks take longer.
Kernighan's law:
[Software] code should be written so that it is easy to read and understand. The clarity and simplicity of code matter more than its brevity or complex structure, because readable code makes a product easier to maintain, debug, and develop further.
How this law works can be seen in letters setting out arguments on any aspect of an immigration case. Long, excessively detailed letters with repeated explanations often have a far less positive effect than brief, precise explanations of the point at issue. A simple, clear "Please issue the work permit with the CUAET notation, because it is essential for obtaining health insurance" works more reliably than a detailed account of every difficulty the applicant has faced because the notation is missing. "Easy to read and understand" is the most important foundation of any letter except a congratulatory one.
Shirky's principle:
Organizations will try to preserve the problem they exist to solve.
There are many examples; consider the LMIA. The process of obtaining that authorization was created to protect Canada's labour market from an excessive influx of foreign workers. Yet today the mechanism exists largely through inertia, consuming substantial government and applicant resources while barely fulfilling its main purpose.
Even IRCC's official website follows this principle: created to give applicants clear and complete information in an accessible form, it is now a cumbersome resource more likely to confuse users, especially those who need a somewhat deeper understanding of the subject.
If the question concerns your situation, a consultation can examine it in detail: you will get answers to all your questions and understand how to proceed correctly.